The MYRO Briefing
Independent Healthcare Intelligence
One doctor, more than one employer, and nobody holding the whole week
On 2 September the Courts and Tribunals Judiciary published a Prevention of Future Deaths report from the Senior Coroner for Dorset, Rachael Griffin, into the death of Dr Naeem Ahmed, a 50-year-old consultant anaesthetist at Poole Hospital. He was found collapsed in a doctors' rest room on the morning of 21 June 2025, during a run of night shifts that had begun on 12 June. The medical cause of death was combined drug and alcohol toxicity, and the inquest concluded misadventure. The coroner could not establish where the drugs had come from.
The report's concerns go well beyond one hospital. A review found that in June 2025 Dr Ahmed undertook clinical work for more than one provider on the same calendar day, including daytime work elsewhere before a resident overnight shift. The trust's systems for job planning, rostering, appraisal and secondary employment "operated independently", so that no one had an integrated view of when he was working or how much.
The coroner recorded that there is no legal requirement for doctors to notify NHS trusts of their private work patterns, or private providers of their NHS work patterns, and was concerned that continuous periods of work without rest could go unseen at other trusts in England and Wales. In other words, the coroner identified gaps in visibility of doctors' combined working patterns across employers, despite existing private-practice disclosure requirements. The report does not find that his working pattern caused his death; the concern is about the future risk of fatigue to patients and doctors. The review that followed led the trust to change its practice on the disposal of drugs and on doctors' working patterns. The report is addressed to the Department of Health and Social Care and to NHS England.
It is not a criticism of independent practice. It describes a gap that a responsible officer in the independent sector also has to manage: many doctors on an independent designated body's roll work elsewhere as well, and the appraisal is one of the few places where their whole working pattern can be brought together, if they set it out.
The whole week, written down
The Dorset report identifies four systems — job planning, rostering, appraisal and secondary employment — each working on its own terms and none of them talking to the others. That description will be familiar to anyone who runs governance for a service staffed by doctors who also hold NHS posts. The clinic knows the sessions it books. The trust knows its rota. Neither necessarily sees the total.
Why it falls to the appraisal
Doctors are already expected to declare the whole of their practice for appraisal and revalidation. But a declaration can be a list of employers rather than an account of time. A list tells a responsible officer where a doctor works. It does not tell anyone whether that doctor is working an NHS night after a private day list, or taking per-request online work between shifts.
This month's featured MPTS case touches the same point. Dr Ravindran held an NHS consultant post and worked, paid per request, for an online telehealth platform, and the tribunal in that case found "a lack of training when enrolling doctors" at the platform. Work of that kind may not feel like a job, but it is still practice, and it still sits within the responsible officer's evaluation.
What a designated body can reasonably ask for
None of this requires new law. Our recommendation is that the appraisal asks a different question: not only "where do you work?" but "when do you work, and for whom?" A doctor who can show their weekly pattern across every organisation, including sessions, on-call, remote and online work, has given the appraiser something to reflect on. Where a doctor cannot, that is worth exploring at appraisal.
Appraisal & Revalidation
Practical Tips & Guidance
Declare the whole week: evidencing every role at appraisal
These cases prompt a practical question: how does a designated body understand a doctor's work across organisations? The appraisal is where that picture can be brought together, if the doctor sets it out.
List every organisation, including the ones that do not feel like employers. Online and telehealth platforms, insurer and medico-legal work, occupational health sessions, teaching and examining, bank and locum shifts. Every medical role counts, paid or unpaid, clinical or non-clinical.
Show the pattern, not just the list. A typical week across all roles: sessions, on-call, out-of-hours and remote work. Note where work for one organisation runs into work for another.
Map each role to its scope. Which procedures, which patient groups, which prescribing — and where any of it is done remotely.
Bring evidence from each role. Complaints, significant events, audit, outcome or complication data and prescribing information from every organisation, not only the one that hosts your appraisal. If a provider will not supply it, record that you asked.
Check indemnity for every role. Do not assume NHS cover extends to private work or a separate online role.
Reflect on the load. Rest, fatigue and the hours between jobs are legitimate subjects for appraisal. The Dorset coroner has raised them as a patient safety concern.
Tell your responsible officer when it changes. A new platform, a new list or a new on-call commitment should not wait for next year's appraisal.
After Thirlwall: the question every employer referral must now answer
Responding on 17 September to Lady Justice Thirlwall's report, the GMC called "deeply concerning" the findings that doctors who raised concerns at the Countess of Chester Hospital were threatened with referral to the regulator. Its General Counsel, Anthony Omo, said: "Our processes must never be used as a weapon against doctors who speak up about patient safety." The GMC restated the safeguard now built into its process: an organisation referring a doctor must disclose whether that doctor has raised concerns, and whether those concerns were investigated. Any designated body making a referral should be ready to answer both questions with evidence. Separately, the Government has committed to a barring scheme for senior NHS leaders who fail in their responsibilities.
Read the GMC statement →
LCS Academy • For doctors and clinical staff
Get Your Mandatory Training Sorted Now
Clinical Staff Mandatory Training: 14 CPD courses for £45 plus VAT, one-off purchase. Indicative 20 hours of CPD, with a certificate for every course.
Get Your Mandatory Training Sorted Now →GMC Watch
Regulatory Updates
High Court: a tribunal must ask whether each act was clinically justified, not whether the examination was
In General Medical Council v Dr Chitlapalli Sathyanath [2026] EWHC 2479 (Admin), handed down on 30 September, Mr Justice Morris allowed the GMC's appeal against a Medical Practitioners Tribunal decision of June 2025.
The facts. Dr Sathyanath, a GP partner in Gosport, saw a 53-year-old patient in September 2022 for follow-up of stomach pain. He admitted that he did not offer a chaperone, did not explain why the examination was needed, did not tell her she could stop it at any time, and did not confirm she was happy to proceed. The tribunal accepted the patient's account that during the examination he placed his hand inside her underwear and brushed it over her pubic bone region, before moving to each side of the groin.
What the tribunal decided. It found serious misconduct, but held that the examination was clinically indicated, that the contact was "inadvertent and not sexually motivated", and that his fitness to practise was not impaired. It gave a warning.
Why the judge disagreed. The tribunal had asked whether the examination was clinically indicated. The allegation concerned two specific acts within it. Asking the wrong question was "an error of principle and an identifiable flaw in its reasoning". The judge substituted a finding that those two acts were not clinically indicated. Because the tribunal's conclusion on sexual motivation had been built on its finding of clinical justification, that conclusion could not stand either. The finding of no impairment is to be quashed and the case returned to a differently constituted tribunal to decide sexual motivation, misconduct and impairment afresh. Those questions are undecided, and nothing here should be read as a finding that the doctor acted with sexual motivation.
Why it matters. Clinical justification attaches to each step of an examination, not to the examination as a whole. A doctor who can explain why abdominal palpation was needed may still be unable to explain a particular movement within it. That applies to every service where examinations go near intimate areas — including cosmetic, body-contouring and hair-restoration consultations — and it is the strongest argument yet for offering a chaperone, obtaining and recording consent, and documenting what was examined and why.
Read the judgment →New guidance on treating children and young people: consultation open to 17 December
The GMC opened consultation on 24 September on Children and young people: care and safeguarding, which would replace 0–18 years (2007) and Protecting children and young people (2012) with a single document covering capacity to consent, best interests, confidentiality, child protection and sexual activity. It applies to doctors, physician associates and anaesthesia associates. Private GPs, and aesthetic and hair clinics that receive requests involving under-18s, should read the draft. The consultation closes on 17 December.
Read about the consultation →Two-thirds of doctors who did not report bullying thought it would make no difference
The GMC's survey of more than 10,500 locally employed and SAS doctors, published on 8 October, found that 23% of locally employed and 31% of SAS doctors had experienced or witnessed bullying or harassment. Of those who did not report it, 67% believed reporting would make no difference, and between 54% and 60% feared the consequences. Internationally qualified doctors reported more micro-aggressions and more exclusion than UK graduates. Chief Executive Charlie Massey: "having reporting procedures in place is not enough." For an independent designated body, the question is not whether a speaking-up policy exists but whether anyone has used it.
Read the GMC news release →MPTS Cases
Fitness to Practise Outcomes
Dr Ravikumar Ravindran — a firearms medical form, three screenshots and a telehealth platform
Outcome: SUSPENSION 6 MONTHS
Dr Ravindran held an NHS consultant post and also worked, paid per request, for Updoc, a digital telehealth platform (hearing 7–22 September 2026; area of practice recorded as "Online"). Through the platform he completed a firearms licensing medical information form and answered "yes" to the questions whether he had had access to the patient's full medical record and whether that record was continuous. He had seen three screenshots from the patient's NHS app. The tribunal found those answers dishonest and that the dishonesty "could have hindered the Police's ability to assess the risk" to the patient. He also issued a fit note for a second patient without sufficient information to support it, and the tribunal found "some financial motivation in completing fit notes".
The tribunal also commented on the platform in this case. It found "a lack of training when enrolling doctors" at Updoc, and that the platform "did not engage in the proceedings and instead chose to protect its own commercial interests". Erasure was rejected: the dishonesty was a single episode, the harm a risk rather than an outcome, and his insight was developing. Six months, with an immediate order and a review, was the minimum to allow remediation.
Why it matters here. The case illustrates the risks of completing medical certificates without obtaining sufficient supporting information. A designated body should know which of its doctors take per-request online work, for whom, and how that work is governed.
Read the MPTS decision →Dr Surrayya Najeeb ERASURE
A locum consultant was told on 19 October 2022 that she was being moved to registrar-level work because of concerns about her ability to work at consultant level. Weeks later she applied for a locum consultant post at another trust with a CV describing her as a respiratory consultant "til present", disclosing neither the concerns nor the move. At interview, she also failed to correct the inaccurate impression that she held a current ACLS certificate. The tribunal found this dishonest. Confronted by the new employer in December 2023, she "flatly denied that these events had taken place, even when presented with evidence". The CV, the application and that denial were also found dishonest; a GMC performance assessment found her clinical management unacceptable. Verify role history with the previous employer, not the CV.
Read the MPTS decision →Dr Lea Cramsie SUSPENSION 10 MONTHS
A Glasgow salaried GP caring for nursing-home residents ticked the box on 31 death certificates, between October 2024 and February 2025, confirming that each death had been reported to the procurator fiscal when it had not — taking those deaths out of review by the Death Certification Review Service. No patient harm was found. The tribunal gave limited weight to her workload explanation and held that even a stressful workload would not excuse dishonesty. A routine form, completed falsely to save time, is still dishonesty.
Read the MPTS decision →Dr Muhammad Khalil SUSPENSION 9 MONTHS
A senior clinical fellow in vascular surgery posted material on Instagram in October 2023 which the tribunal found objectively antisemitic and seriously offensive, one post intended to support violence. His profile carried images of him in scrubs and his first post "clearly identified him as a doctor". For doctors who market themselves on social media, the account is professional whether or not they think of it that way.
Read the MPTS decision →Dr Rachael Bartrum CONDITIONS 12 MONTHS
A GP found impaired in 2023, after consulting 22 patients while under the influence of alcohol and following two drink-driving convictions, remains impaired at review. Her conditions put the responsible officer at the centre: the RO appoints her workplace reporter and approves her clinical supervisor, she needs RO and GMC adviser approval before any locum, out-of-hours or on-call work, and she must tell her RO of every organisation she works for, including any practising privileges. This is what conditions ask of a designated body in practice.
Read the MPTS decision →
LCS Academy • For your non-clinical team
Essential Training for Non-Clinical Staff
Statutory and mandatory training for receptionists, administrators and managers in private clinics and independent hospitals in England. Eighteen modules, with modules 1–10 mapped to the Core Skills Training Framework. Indicative 12 hours of CPD, £45 plus VAT, one-off purchase.
Train Your Non-Clinical Team →Industry Intelligence
Independent Healthcare Sector
HIS imposed an emergency treatment restriction on Dumfries clinic on 8 October
On 8 October Healthcare Improvement Scotland served an emergency condition notice on Clinique De Visage Limited, Dumfries, prohibiting any healthcare treatment or any procedure in Schedule 1 of the new Non-surgical Procedures and Functions of Medical Reviewers (Scotland) Act 2026, with immediate effect. HIS gave as its grounds the volume and nature of the improvements required and the lack of a suitably qualified healthcare professional while service users were present. An Improvement Notice published on 15 October sets eleven improvements by 6 November — among them a prescriber on site during dermal filler treatments, stock medicines prescribed only to individual patients, one reconstituted toxin vial per patient per session, and documented consent for unlicensed use. HIS has said it will propose cancelling registration if there is no significant improvement.
Read the Improvement Notice →Two doctors under practising privileges, and no record of their checks
At its first inspection of The Women's Clinic, Glasgow, on 16 July (report published 14 October), Healthcare Improvement Scotland found two GMC-registered doctors providing minor surgery under practising privileges contracts. The provider said background checks had been done, but HIS found no evidence to demonstrate this, and no record of ongoing checks such as GMC registration status, revalidation or indemnity renewal. The clinic was graded Satisfactory in all three areas, with eight requirements and eight recommendations. Separately, at its August inspection of DH Medical Aesthetics in Kirkcaldy, graded Good in every area, HIS made one immediate requirement because a vascular occlusion had not been notified to it within the expected timescale.
Read the inspection report →ASA rules weight-loss advertising indirectly promoted prescription-only medicines
On 7 October the ASA upheld complaints against five online weight-loss providers. In the adverts examined, appetite and craving claims indicated a prescription-only medicine even though none was named, and the landing page behind a paid social advert was treated as part of the advert. On 2 October the MHRA reported that nine providers had changed their marketing after its action, stating that customers and previous customers "do not cease to be members of the public" — promotional emails and texts that lead to a prescription-only medicine are not appropriate.
Read the ASA ruling →£2 million of counterfeit weight-loss pens seized in Birmingham
The MHRA and West Midlands Police seized more than 12,000 fake retatrutide and tirzepatide pens, with packaging for around 30,000 more, from an industrial unit in Birmingham on 14 October. Retatrutide is not authorised for use in the UK. The MHRA warned that the products had not been assessed for safety, quality or effectiveness and their contents were unknown. Clinicians managing patients on GLP-1 treatment should ask where any supply came from.
Read the MHRA announcement →MPs: any GMC-registered doctor can still perform cosmetic surgery
The Commons Women and Equalities Committee reported on 11 September that the Government had still not responded to its February report, nor published the consultation on draft regulations it had said would come in June. It recommends immediate restrictions on the highest-risk procedures, and that anyone performing invasive surgical cosmetic procedures have specialist training and board certification. It records the surgical bodies' warning that any GMC-registered doctor may legally perform procedures such as breast augmentation, rhinoplasty, facelifts or liposuction without being on the Specialist Register.
Read the committee report →Criminal caution for unregistered laser treatment
Healthcare Inspectorate Wales cautioned a Cardiff provider under the Care Standards Act 2000 on 2 October, after a criminal investigation, for providing aesthetic laser treatment between October 2024 and November 2025 without registering. In Wales, a service using IPL or a class 3B or 4 laser must register as an independent hospital. HIW's annual report warned on 24 September that current arrangements "may not provide sufficient oversight" of laser and aesthetic treatments.
Read the HIW announcement →Fewer than a third of inspected fertility clinics fully compliant
The HFEA's Fertility Sector 2025/26 report, published on 15 October, records 141 non-compliances across 94 inspections, 7 critical and 69 major, and finds 29% of inspected clinics with treatment or storage licences fully compliant at the time of inspection. Incidents, near misses and cases awaiting classification rose 19% to 942; the HFEA says over 99% of cycles took place without a reportable incident and regards the rise in reporting as a positive sign of an open reporting culture. 67% of treatment clinics are privately owned. In September the HFEA also restated that consent to the use of embryos can be withdrawn by a patient, partner or donor at any time before treatment, and that clinics must make sure patients understand this before they consent.
Read the HFEA report →Regulators ask NICE to act on propranolol for anxiety
In an open letter published on 7 October, the GPhC's Chief Pharmacy Officer, the Patient Safety Commissioner for England, the Royal College of Pharmacy and the College of Mental Health Pharmacy asked NICE to update its anxiety guideline (CG113) to state plainly that propranolol is not recommended for anxiety disorders, to highlight that it is highly toxic in overdose with no specific antidote, and — where clinicians prescribe it anyway — to advise on assessing suicide and self-harm risk and limiting quantities. The letter cites coroners' reports of fatal overdoses. Doctors prescribing propranolol for anxiety, including in private and remote consultations, should review how they assess risk and how much they supply.
Read the open letter →Subscribe to The MYRO Briefing
Delivered free to your inbox each month. Regulatory developments, MPTS decisions, and practical guidance for responsible officers and designated bodies.
Subscribe Free →